link to ringley website
  • Home
  • About Us
    About us & leadership Awards Savings for Clients Case Studies Green Management Strategies Market Overview Leasehold Reform Campaign Money Back Guarantee
  • Our Services
    • Asset Management
      • UK Asset Management
      • Project Monitoring
      • ESG Consultancy & Implementation
      • PropTech & Living Sectors Platform
      • Marketing Insights
      • Resident Journey
      • Stabilised Assets
      • UK Build to Rent
      • UK Later Living
      • UK Co-Living
      • UK Student Accommodation
      • UK Single Family Housing
    • Block Management
      • Overview - London
      • Overview - Wales & West
      • Overview - Southwest
      • Right to Manage
      • Freehold Management
      • Resident Management
      • Estates of Houses
      • Ground Rent Collection
      • How to change agent?
      • Block Management Services
      • Can't afford an agent?
      • Legal & Tribunals
      • Top 10 Tips
      • Report an incident
    • Commercial Management
    • Law
      • Overview
      • Meet The Team
      • Recommendations
      • Right to Manage
      • Lease Extensions
      • Freehold Purchase
      • Absentee Freeholder
      • Court Appointed Manager
      • Conveyancing - Wales
      • Conveyancing - England
      • Service Charge/Rent Arrears Recovery
      • Company Secretary
    • Property Valuations
      • Overview
      • Loan Security
      • Company Accounts
      • Lease Extensions
      • Freehold Purchase
      • Rent Reviews
      • Ground Rent Investment
      • Development Valuations
      • Expert Witness & Litigation
      • Tax, Trusts & Accounts Valuations
      • Trading Business
      • Compulsory Purchase
      • Residential Valuations
    • Engineering
      • Overview
      • EWS1 Consultancy
      • Asbestos
      • Contract Administration
      • Fire Assesment
      • Homebuyer Survey
      • Building Survey
      • Schedules
      • Party Wall Matters
      • Principle Designer
      • Disability Access Audits
      • Small Building Works
      • Fire Door Inspection
      • Insurance Valuations
    • Property Accounting
      • Finance
      • Quote For Service Charge Accounts?
      • Property Accounting Law
      • Accounting Updates
      • To Audit or Not?
    • Plant & Facilities Management
      • Plant & Facilities Management
      • Fire Door Inspection APP
      • Fire Safety Update
    • Site Staffing Solutions
      • Ringley Integrated Site Staff Solutions
    • Leasehold Guidance
      • Overview
      • Right to Manage
      • Purchasing The Freehold
      • Court Appointed Manager
      • Absentee Freeholder
  • Insights
    Asset Management Articles Block Management Blogs Publications BTR Rental Market Blogs Customer Insights FAQ - Ask Our Experts Insurance Calculator
  • ESG
  • E-books
  • Get In Touch
  •    
  • Work with us
  •  
  • Portal Login
Industry Updates: Decision Affecting Leaseholders of Defective Buildings

Written by: Kate Robinson 08/08/2023
  509       0
Responsive image

Landmark Decision Affecting Leaseholders in Defective Buildings

The Building Safety Act 2022 is the most significant step by the UK government in response to the Grenfell Tower tragedy. The enormous act comprises several sections and schedules detailing stringent rules that cover the planning, occupation, and construction of specific properties. The recent decision by the property tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>tribunal highlights the first major effect of the Building Safety Act in favour of leaseholders.

Property tribunal backs leaseholders

Property tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>tribunal backs leaseholders

In a landmark ruling, the First Tier tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>Tribunal (FTT) referred to the Building Safety Act 2022 to direct the developer to pay back £200,000 to leaseholders, which the developers charged wrongly. The amount was in connection with the payment to remove the cladding and replace unsafe balconies. It is the first type of order concerning the remediation of building defects that can threaten the building's safety. Inspired, Sutton was to develop the site and sell the freehold. The property had several flaws, including the height of the dry riser. Additionally, a car parking space was situated in front of the dry riser, blocking access. It posed a life-endangering risk to the upper floors in the event of a fire, as firefighters will have no access to these floors.

Arjun Batish and 18 leaseholders revolted against the prospect of sharing the bill of £18,000 because the government grant of £1 million did not cover the expenses to remove the defective balconies. The grant was only for the removal of the cladding. Batish struggled with no support from lawyers as the legal expenses were too high.

Knowing the legal background

Knowing the legal background

Arjun Batish has no legal background, but he studied the Building Safety Act in detail to find the relevant sections and schedule to back his argument. Section 122 of the Building Safety Act 2022 deals with the remediation of costs and makes a provision to recover the cost of repairs for relevant defects from landlords. It also mentions that leaseholders need not pay servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charges if the landlord or their associate is responsible for defects.

Many leaseholders have to pay exorbitant servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charges as part of their contribution to fund remedial repairs. The confusion about who should pay for remedial works is delaying repairs in several buildings, causing severe safety risks to residents. Several properties remain in unsafe conditions despite the passage of six years since the Grenfell Tower disaster. Thankfully, the Building Safety Act provides several measures to make the parties responsible for building defects pay for the remedial measures. The Remedial Contribution Order (RCO) of the Building Safety Act 2022 mentions that the developer must pay the remediation costs to repair relevant defects. A relevant defect is anything that impacts the safety of the building or causes the fire to spread across the building.

Encouraging decision of First Tier Tribunal

Encouraging decision of First Tier tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>Tribunal

Arjun Batish and other leaseholders applied for a Remediation Contribution Order (RCO) to the First Tier tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>Tribunal. The RCO has powers to order the landlord or developer to take responsibility for repairs of relevant defects or reimburse the amount if the leaseholders contributed to the payment of repairs. The leaseholders applied to the First Tier tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>Tribunal seeking reimbursement of remediation costs, amounting to £192,635.64. The leaseholders paid the sum towards the contribution to repair the costs of repairing relevant defects relating to external defects impacting the building's safety.

The decision of the First Tier tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>Tribunal to exercise the powers of the Remedial Contribution Order is encouraging for the leaseholders. It is a historical decision in the interest of leaseholders. The application had the unique exception of not being a contested one. The tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>tribunal barred the landlord from participating, facilitating the decision in favour of the leaseholders.

Visit Ringley Popular pages:
Page 1: Ringley Group

Page 2: Leasehold Guidance
Page 3: Ringley FAQs
Page 4: Ringley Blog

Property Tribunal Backs Leaseholders in Historic Decision

In a landmark ruling, the First Tier tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>Tribunal (FTT) referred to the Building Safety Act 2022, directing a developer to repay £200,000 to leaseholders. This amount was originally charged to cover the cost of removing dangerous cladding and replacing unsafe balconies. The ruling marks the first significant application of the Building Safety Act’s provisions related to building safety and defect remediation, providing a vital precedent for future cases.

Encouraging Decision Paves the Way for Leaseholder Rights

The tenancy-agreements-made-easy'>planetrent.co.uk/blog/could-a-tax-tribunal-ruling-mean-btl-investors-avoid-3-stamp-duty-surcharge'>tribunal’s decision to support the leaseholders and order the reimbursement of £192,635.64 for remediation costs highlights a major turning point for leaseholders grappling with building defects. The ruling underscores the importance of the Remedial Contribution Order (RCO) within the Building Safety Act, reinforcing that developers and landlords must take responsibility for unsafe buildings. This decision offers hope for leaseholders and sets an important legal precedent for future cases involving building safety issues.



Property Management Block Management Building Safety
POPULAR POSTS

Solar panels on flats - what you need to know

Is noise getting you down?

Ground Rent: Fines for Landlords Who Charge Ground Rent

High Court: Right to Rent does breach human rights

Landlords beware - Don't believe everything you read!

RECENT POSTS

Private Landlord Exodus Accelerates as Reforms and Rising Costs Pressure Rental Market

Freeholders claim Human Rights infringed in Legal Battle Over Leasehold Reforms

Freeholders Win Early Round in Legal Battle Over Leasehold Reforms

New Standards for Smart Appliances Aim to Reduce Household Energy Bills

HMO Investment and Mortgage Trends in the UK: Q1 2025 Overview



Blogs related:

ASSET MANAGEMENT
Step by step guide to lease extensions
Whilst your lease is probably the most valuable asset you own, worth whatever you could sell it for in the market place, the freeholder holds a stake in its value too. Why, because a) he receives investment income from it (the ground rent), b) has the hope value of a premium from you (for buying a lease extension) and c) holds the reversionary interest (the value of it vacant flat in X years time when your lease runs out).Step 1 - establish if...

Read


ASSET MANAGEMENT
MPs demand reimposition of stringent energy efficiency rules for landlords
After the UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak recently reversed the stringent energy efficiency rules for landlords, MPs from various opposition parties have urged the government and the PM to reconsider the decision.Has Rishi Sunak stopped EPC Reforms in the UK?Prime Minister Sunak discarded proposals in October 2023 that sought to mandate landlords to boost the energy efficiency levels of their properties. While these plans had not yet been formal...

Read


ASSET MANAGEMENT
What is on Ringley's Budget wish list?
New Chancellor Rishi Sunak delivers his first budget tomorrow. Here are the issues that Ringley Group MD Maryanne Bowring is hoping he will address.Tax breaks for those supporting housing provisionRe-zoning for all our ailing high streets and government investment in master planning to promote housing, Planning Development rights and subsidies or business rates linked to turnover (aka turnover rates) to encourage leisure, cafe and restaurant b...

Read


Meet our Expert Property Commentators

Mary-Anne Bowring FTPI FRICS FARLA FCABE Founder/Head of Asset Management

Strategic partnerships, holistic delivery/ opportunities, growth, value engineering, thought leadership

Ian Barber MD BTR Mobilisation & Leasing

Runs HQ & site lease-up teams. Drives rent pricing, mobilisation, marketing, happy residents!

Jon Curtis MRICS Head of Building Engineering

Chartered Building Surveyor. Lectures on EWS1 & building safety. Runs CapEx programmes.

Kate Robinson MTPI MD Blocks/FM Management (London Region)

Master plan setup, ops and staffing and resident engagement. ISO45001 champion.

Lee Harle Partner Ringley Law

Plot conveyancing. Debt litigation. Group Company Secretary.

Natalie Birmingham Helpdesk Support Manager

Trainer & Helpdesk Manager: people, systems,contractors. ISO45001 supply chain accreditation.

Chris Georgalis MRICS Head of Commercial Valuation

Chartered Valuer. Rental valuations: retail, leisure. IRR modelling and valuations for secured lending. Compulsory purchase & rent reviews

Nichola Pughe MRICS Head of Residential Valuation

Chartered Valuer. Rental development & mixed use valuations, IRR modelling. Leasehold enfranchisement specialist


Insights, articles & blogs
INDEX

PROPERTY
BLOGS

LANDLORD
BLOGS

PROPERTY
ARTICLES

E-BOOKS

inshights shared - link to planetrent blogs

Landlord blog
Read landlord blog
inshights shared - link to ringley blogs

Property blogs
Read property blogs
inshights shared - link to ringley articles

Property articles
Read property articles
inshights shared - link to ringley ebooks

E-books
Read E-books

link to ringley social media facebook link to ringley social media instagram link to ringley social media linkedin link to ringley social media x-twitter
link to ringley social media x-twitter for small device
link to ringley social media linkedin for small device
link to ringley social media instagram for small device
link to ringley social media facebook for small device
  • Ringley Group
  • About us
  • CSR / ESG
  • BusyLiving
  • PlanetRent
  • Talk to us
  • Careers
  • Ask a Question
  • Insights
  • Articles
  • Blogs
  • Subscribe
  • BTR & PRS Buildings
  • What we do
  • Asset Management
  • Block Management
  • Facilities Management
  • Property Law
  • Surveying / Valuation
  • Building Engineering
  • Financial Services
  • Managing Agents
  • Block Management Locations
  • Co-working
  • Renting & Letting
  • Right to Manage
  • Contractor Management
  • Space to Work
  • Fees and Client Money Protections
  • Email: solutions@ringley.co.uk

  • Emergency line 1: 0207 428 2056

  • Emergency line 2: 0207 267 2900

  • Report an incident
  • Our Offices
  • London
  • Ringley House
  • 1 Castle Road
  • London
  • NW1 8PR
  • T: 0207 267 2900
  • London
  • Ringley House
  • 47 Rochester Place
  • London
  • NW1 9JL
  • Manchester
  • 11 Swan Street
  • Northern Quarter
  • Manchester
  • M4 5JJ
  • T: 0330 174 7777
  • Cardiff
  • 122 West Bute Street
  • Cardiff Bay
  • Cardiff
  • CF10 5LJ
  • T: 0330 174 7747
Privacy Policy
Ringley Staff Dashboard
link to ifsm website link to tpos website link to rics website link to ukgbc website link to government security industry authority website link to alep website

All content © copyright 2025. Ringley Limited. All Rights reserved. Ringley Limited, incorporated and registered in England and wales. Registered office: Ringley House, 1 Castle Road, London, NW1 8PR. Company No. 03302438
Terms of use | Privacy Policy | Modern slavery act | COVID-19 risk assessment