Rinlgley group logo
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    About Us Our People Awards Savings for Clients Results for Clients Green Management Strategies Market Overview Leasehold Reform Campaign Money Back Guarantee
  • What We Do
    • Block Management
      • Block Management Overview
      • for RTM Companies
      • for Freehold Management Companies
      • for Resident Management Companies
      • for Estates of Houses
      • for Freeholder Investors
      • Ground Rent Collection
      • How to Change Agent
      • Block Management Packages
      • Can't Afford an Agent?
      • Legal work & Tribunals
      • Section 20 Major Works
      • Ringley's Top 10 Tips
      • Staff on Site
      • Moving or Buying?
      • Report an Incident
    • Asset Management
      • Asset Management Overview
        • Asset Management Overview
        • Stabilised Assets
        • Project Monitoring
        • Mobilisation & Lease up
        • Asset Managers TechStack
        • Accounting & Reporting
        • Brands & URLs for sale
        • ESG Consultancy & Implementation
        • UK Build to Rent
        • UK Later Living
        • UK Coliving
        • UK Student Housing
        • BTR Smart PropTech
        • BTR Strategic Marketing
        • BTR Resident Experience
        • BTR Tenancy Management
        • Asset Management Clients
        • Site Finding/Digital Land Search
      • Law
        • Legal Services Overview
        • Our People
        • Recommendations
        • Right to Manage
        • Lease Extensions
        • Freehold Purchase
        • Absentee Freeholder
        • Court Appointed Manager
        • Conveyancing
        • Service Charge/Rent Arrears Recovery
        • Company Secretary
      • Valuation
        • Valuation Overview
        • Loan Security
        • Company Accounts
        • Lease Extensions
        • Freehold Purchase
        • Rent Reviews
        • Development Valuations
        • Insurance Valuations
        • Expert Witness & Litigation
        • Tax, Trusts & Accounts Valuations
        • Trading Business
        • Compulsory Purchase
        • Residential Valuations
      • Engineering
        • Engineering Overview
        • EWS1 Consultancy
        • Asbestos
        • Contract Administration
        • Fire Assesment
        • Homebuyer Survey
        • Building Survey
        • Schedules
        • Party Wall Matters
        • Principle Designer
        • Disability Access Audits
        • Small Building Works
      • Finance
        • Finance Overview
        • Get Accounts Quote
        • The Law & Property Accounts
        • Industry Update
        • To audit or Not?
      • Plant & Facilities Management
        • Plant & Facilities Management
        • Fire Door Inspection APP
      • Site Staffing Solutions
      • Leasehold Guidance
        • Leasehold Guidance Overview
        • Right to Manage
        • Buy Freehold
        • Court Appointed Manager
        • Absentee Freeholder
    • Insights
      Property Management Articles Property Management Blogs Rental Market Blogs Customer Comments FAQ - Ask Our Experts
    • E-books
    • Portal Login
    • Get In Touch

    Using pensions to buy houses will be a disaster for property prices & your retirement

    by Mary-Anne Bowring/UK Investor Magazine


    Pensions Minister, Guy Opperman, said in a webinar that he wanted to explore ways for the auto-enrolment pension system to be adjusted, to allow buyers to borrow from their pension pots for property deposits.

    Today’s fire sale will mean fewer people will buy tomorrow
    Much like the myopic and expedient stamp duty holiday, the risk with this next proposal on the ‘Generation Buy’ playlist is that it would artificially inflate short-term demand. Then, the ensuing buying spree would likely trigger a corresponding, rapid and – for future first-time buyers – harmful rise in property prices. This spike in demand would be unlikely to be matched by a surge in supply, as knowingly pushing existing property owners into negative equity is a huge no-no. Therefore, should such a spike occur, it would be here to stay (COVID and mass unemployment permitting).

    While dipping into pension pots might build a short-term ‘Generation Buy’, we appear to have forgotten the lessons of Right-to-Buy. If we offer a one-time fire sale to today’s buyers, the first-time buyers of tomorrow will see property ownership as an increasingly distant dream. What should instead be the goal is a consistent supply of housing stock (including social housing), alongside efforts to align property prices with inflation.

    Pensions or pittance?
    Further, even if we blindly skip into a place where this policy exists (which would be necessary to make you think think it’s a good idea), we must consider the issue of compound interest. As stated by Isabelle Fraser, “a small amount taken out of a pension now [- in order to afford a deposit -] turns into a much larger shortfall after decades of missed growth.”

    The OECD declared that the majority of today’s youngsters will retire with 60% less than current retirees, and that millenials wanting to retire at the same age as their grandparents will have to save an additional £80,000. With this in mind, Boris’ latest gambit isn’t just reckless for property prices, but could be truly devastating for pensioners of the future.

    Even if today’s buyers survive by using their pension pot to buy property, and then build on that and pay for their retirement – what about the people after them, and the people after that? If we are encouraged to use up larger and larger chunks of our pension pot to buy a house, at what point will people reach retirement age and have to choose between their home and sufficient liquid capital to pay the bills? In short, this latest proposal is an indictment of policies trying to deal with complex issues, too quickly.

    No guarantee banks will even accept pension pot deposits
    Another major oversight with this new proposal is that it seems to ignore the situation going on right in front of us, regarding mortgage approvals. Having pledged to lower mortgage deposit rates to 5%, the PM didn’t seem to address one of the core reasons why mortgage applications are getting denied so regularly. Certainly, deposit size is an issue, but so too, is the provenance of the deposit.

    As I was told by a property-focused solicitor, banks don’t just want to know if you have the money, but where it has come from – because that gives a lot of indication of whether they can rely on more coming. For instance, if your mortgage deposit is courtesy of the bank of mum and dad, you’re far more likely to be rejected. What banks want is a deposit generated organically by working groups or individuals, with steady and reliable incomes, not one-off sums followed by promises.

    I don’t see how this differs from drawing money out of a pension pot. It’s a one-off sum of money that doesn’t exactly reflect your month-to-month ability to pay a mortgage. While pension contributions are based on an individual’s salary, they don’t take account of things like one’s cost of living, job security, or financial prudence. With this in mind, I’m not sure whether banks would accept pension-pot-based deposits – and given what we’ve discussed, that’s probably for the better.

    Are pensions and property investment ever compatible?
    In some capacity, they already are. Indeed, pension funds have invested in real estate for some time, and , according to Ringley Managing Director, Mary-Anne Bowring:

    “People are correct to look at pensions as a solution to the housing crisis but encouraging young people to pull money from their pension pots to buy a home is deeply irresponsible. “

    “There is a historic opportunity to harness pension fund cash that was previously being invested into shopping centres and offices into delivering new homes for rent. Many pension funds are already investing significantly in so-called ‘build to rent’ homes across the UK.”

    “This asset class is perfect for investment from pension funds, as they require long-term steady income streams to match their liabilities.”

    “There’s a considerable undersupply of high-quality rental homes in this country and all indicators point to more people renting and for longer, underlining the need to deliver more rental housing.”

    Of course, this latter point is exactly what Boris is trying to avoid. What he wants is for more people to buy, and to do so at a younge rage. And, though a worthy goal, this latest proposal is short-sighted, and gives little thought to posterity.


    https://ukinvestormagazine.co.uk/using-pensions-to-buy-houses-will-be-a-disaster-for-property-prices-your-retirement/

    Responsive image Responsive image
    Subscription

    Keep up to date

    (Weekly, fortnightly or monthly)


    To find out more what we do with your data, please read our Privacy Policy


    Insights, Blogs, Research, E-Books

    Landlord blog bg

    Landlord blog
    Read landlord blog
    Property blog bg

    Property blogs
    Read property blogs
    Articles bg

    Property articles
    Read property articles
    E book

    E-books
    Read E-books
    Facebook footer Instagram footer Linkedin footer Twitter footer
    Facebook footer
    Instagram footer
    Linkedin footer
    Twitter footer
    • Ringley Group
    • About us
    • CSR
    • BusyLiving
    • PlanetRent
    • Fire door inspection
    • Talk to us
    • Careers
    • Ask a Question
    • Insight
    • Articles
    • Blogs
    • Subscribe
    • What we do
    • Asset Management
    • Block Management
    • Facilities Management
    • Property Law
    • Surveying / Valuation
    • Building Engineering
    • Financial Services
    • Managing Agents
    • Block Management Locations
    • Co-working
    • Offices
    • London
    • Ringley House
    • 1 Castle Road
    • London
    • NW1 8PR
    • T: 0207 267 2900
    • Manchester
    • 11 Swan Street
    • Northern Quarter
    • Manchester
    • M4 5JJ
    • T: 0330 174 7777
    • Cardiff
    • 122 Bute Street
    • Cardiff Bay
    • Cardiff
    • CF10 5AE
    • T: 0330 174 7747
    • Email: solutions@ringley.co.uk
    • Emergency line 1: 0207 428 2056
    • Emergency line 2: 0207 267 2900
    • Report incident
    Privacy Policy
    Ringley Staff
    Ifsm Irpm member New iso Arla licensed Ombudsman services Rics vertical Gbc

    All content © copyright 2022. Ringley Limited. All Rights reserved. Ringley Limited, incorporated and registered in England and wales. Registered office: Ringley House, 1 Castle Road, London, NW1 8PR. Company No. 03302438
    Terms of use | Privacy Policy | Modern slavery act | COVID-19 risk assessment