link to ringley website
  • Home
  • About Us
    About us & leadership Awards Savings for Clients Case Studies Green Management Strategies Market Overview Leasehold Reform Campaign Money Back Guarantee
  • Our Services
    • Asset Management
      • UK Asset Management
      • Project Monitoring
      • ESG Consultancy & Implementation
      • PropTech & Living Sectors Platform
      • Marketing Insights
      • Resident Journey
      • Stabilised Assets
      • UK Build to Rent
      • UK Later Living
      • UK Co-Living
      • UK Student Accommodation
      • UK Single Family Housing
    • Block Management
      • Overview - London
      • Overview - Wales & West
      • Overview - Southwest
      • Right to Manage
      • Freehold Management
      • Resident Management
      • Estates of Houses
      • Ground Rent Collection
      • How to change agent?
      • Block Management Services
      • Can't afford an agent?
      • Legal & Tribunals
      • Top 10 Tips
      • Report an incident
    • Commercial Management
    • Law
      • Overview
      • Meet The Team
      • Recommendations
      • Right to Manage
      • Lease Extensions
      • Freehold Purchase
      • Absentee Freeholder
      • Court Appointed Manager
      • Conveyancing - Wales
      • Conveyancing - England
      • Service Charge/Rent Arrears Recovery
      • Company Secretary
    • Property Valuations
      • Overview
      • Loan Security
      • Company Accounts
      • Lease Extensions
      • Freehold Purchase
      • Rent Reviews
      • Ground Rent Investment
      • Development Valuations
      • Expert Witness & Litigation
      • Tax, Trusts & Accounts Valuations
      • Trading Business
      • Compulsory Purchase
      • Residential Valuations
    • Engineering
      • Overview
      • EWS1 Consultancy
      • Asbestos
      • Contract Administration
      • Fire Assesment
      • Homebuyer Survey
      • Building Survey
      • Schedules
      • Party Wall Matters
      • Principle Designer
      • Disability Access Audits
      • Small Building Works
      • Fire Door Inspection
      • Insurance Valuations
    • Property Accounting
      • Finance
      • Quote For Service Charge Accounts?
      • Property Accounting Law
      • Accounting Updates
      • To Audit or Not?
    • Plant & Facilities Management
      • Plant & Facilities Management
      • Fire Door Inspection APP
      • Fire Safety Update
    • Site Staffing Solutions
      • Ringley Integrated Site Staff Solutions
    • Leasehold Guidance
      • Overview
      • Right to Manage
      • Purchasing The Freehold
      • Court Appointed Manager
      • Absentee Freeholder
  • Insights
    Asset Management Articles Block Management Blogs Publications BTR Rental Market Blogs Customer Insights FAQ - Ask Our Experts Insurance Calculator
  • ESG
  • E-books
  • Get In Touch
  •    
  • Work with us
  •  
  • Portal Login
Industry Updates: Service Charge Dispute In The Supreme Court

Written by: Mary-Anne Bowring 11/07/2023
  377       0
Responsive image

Service Charge Dispute In The Supreme Court

The UK Supreme Court has ruled against a retail tenant in an ongoing servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge dispute with its previous landlord. The decision is expected to have major implications for commercial landlords and tenants. While the tenant's final appeal has been dismissed, the court's decision creates an opportunity for other tenants to challenge or recover amounts imposed by their landlords in similar cases.

The Supreme Court rules that a tenant disputing a verified servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge levied by their landlord must first pay the charge in full. They also stated that any arguments against the charge, except for fraud claims or obvious mistakes, could be raised later in the legal process.

The right to set off against service charges is quashed

According to the Supreme Court, a landlord's servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge certificate was binding regarding the tenant's specific amount to pay. However, the certificate did not establish the tenant's overall responsibility for the servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge. In simpler terms, the tenant was obliged to make the payment but retained the right to challenge it later.

The history of the case

The dispute in question is a case between landlord Sara & Hossein Asset Holdings Limited (S&H) and former tenant Blacks Outdoor Retail Limited (Blacks) regarding interpreting a certification provision in their lease agreement for retail premises in Liverpool. The court's ruling, outlined in a 22-page document, focused on the relevant clause stating that S&H should provide a certificate specifying the total cost and the amount payable by the tenant.

This certificate would be considered conclusive, except in "manifest or mathematical error or fraud."

S&H argued that this provision aligned with commercial reality, allowing them to promptly collect servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charges for the provided services and avoid lengthy and costly litigation to recover expenses related to maintaining the premises. On the other hand, Blacks contended that the certificate issued by S&H was only conclusive regarding S&H's costs, not the actual amount they were required to pay. They argued that their ability to challenge the determined amount under the "manifest or mathematical error" defense was too limited.

What Triggered The Dispute And The Subsequent Court Case

Blacks had failed to pay the servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge for 2017/18 and 2018/19, with the servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge for the 2017/18 period alone amounting to over 400,000. However, Blacks claimed that the sums in the certificates were extreme and included sums not due under the leases. The High Court had supported Blacks interpretation of the servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge provisions that the certificate was conclusive only regarding the amount of costs incurred by Sara but not as to Blacks servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge liability. It allowed Blacks to challenge the demand, and Sara appealed the judgment.

The Court of Appeal granted the appeal and issued a summary judgment in Sara's favor. They determined that the interpretation of the servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge provisions indicated that the certificate served as conclusive evidence for the total costs and the specific amount owed by Blacks.

The Supreme Courts Stand

In a majority ruling of four to one, the Supreme Court concluded that a landlord's certificate regarding the "total cost and the sum payable by the tenant" was conclusive in determining the specific amount to be paid by the tenant. However, the court also clarified that the certificate did not establish the underlying liability for the servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge.

The judgment delivered by Lord Hamblen on behalf of the majority emphasized the clause did not function as a "pay now, argue never" but rather as a "pay now, argue later" provision. As the tenant, the Blacks had an obligation to pay their servicechargesorted.co.uk/blogs/digital-solution-can-improve-the-whole-process-by-making-it-faster-and-more-transparent'>service charge debt while still retaining the opportunity to counterclaim for reimbursement of any costs they believed were wrongly charged. The Supreme Court also made it clear that, due to the lease's absence of a set-off provision, it is unlikely that any request to suspend the payment claim while awaiting the resolution of the counterclaim would be granted.

In his dissenting note, Lord Briggs stated that he failed to find any language within the lease supporting the interpretation of "pay now, argue later." He pointed out that if such an intention existed between the parties, it could have been stipulated in the lease agreement.

Visit Ringley Popular pages:
Page 1: Ringley Group

Page 2: Leasehold Guidance
Page 3: Ringley FAQs
Page 4: Ringley Blog



Property Management Block Management Building Safety
POPULAR POSTS

Solar panels on flats - what you need to know

Is noise getting you down?

Ground Rent: Fines for Landlords Who Charge Ground Rent

High Court: Right to Rent does breach human rights

Landlords beware - Don't believe everything you read!

RECENT POSTS

Private Landlord Exodus Accelerates as Reforms and Rising Costs Pressure Rental Market

Freeholders claim Human Rights infringed in Legal Battle Over Leasehold Reforms

Freeholders Win Early Round in Legal Battle Over Leasehold Reforms

New Standards for Smart Appliances Aim to Reduce Household Energy Bills

HMO Investment and Mortgage Trends in the UK: Q1 2025 Overview



Blogs related:

ASSET MANAGEMENT
Net Zero:  A call to change leasehold law if flat owners are to help 
Owning a leasehold property means you have the right to live in a property for a fixed period, but you do not own the land beneath it. As a result, making sustainable modifications is not straightforward.Leaseholders cannot make substantial changes without permission from the freeholder.A license to alter is often required, making even internal improvements challenging.External improvements, such as solar panels or insulation upgrades, are oft...

Read


ASSET MANAGEMENT
UK Government Initiates Landlord Clampdown, Announces Measures to Protect Tenants
The tragic death of Awaab Ishak from exposure to spores in the family’s rented flat in the UK has stirred up a huge controversy. The Awaab family says they had repeatedly raised the mould problem with the property owners, Rochdale Boroughwide Housing (RBH), but that they did nothing of value except scrubbing and painting the walls occasionally.

Read


ASSET MANAGEMENT
Open Banking - Concerns, benefits and other vital aspects of this powerful platform
Open Banking has been acknowledged as a wonderful technology that can bring far-reaching changes to the housing sector in the UK. However, there are many misconceptions in the stakeholders' minds regarding the technology's effectiveness. Is it a secure resource for all your financial data, or are there some loopholes that can leak information? Certain misunderstandings persist about Open Banking, but many individuals recognise it as a reliable...

Read


Meet our Expert Property Commentators

Mary-Anne Bowring FTPI FRICS FARLA FCABE Founder/Head of Asset Management

Strategic partnerships, holistic delivery/ opportunities, growth, value engineering, thought leadership

Ian Barber MD BTR Mobilisation & Leasing

Runs HQ & site lease-up teams. Drives rent pricing, mobilisation, marketing, happy residents!

Jon Curtis MRICS Head of Building Engineering

Chartered Building Surveyor. Lectures on EWS1 & building safety. Runs CapEx programmes.

Kate Robinson MTPI MD Blocks/FM Management (London Region)

Master plan setup, ops and staffing and resident engagement. ISO45001 champion.

Lee Harle Partner Ringley Law

Plot conveyancing. Debt litigation. Group Company Secretary.

Natalie Birmingham Helpdesk Support Manager

Trainer & Helpdesk Manager: people, systems,contractors. ISO45001 supply chain accreditation.

Chris Georgalis MRICS Head of Commercial Valuation

Chartered Valuer. Rental valuations: retail, leisure. IRR modelling and valuations for secured lending. Compulsory purchase & rent reviews

Nichola Pughe MRICS Head of Residential Valuation

Chartered Valuer. Rental development & mixed use valuations, IRR modelling. Leasehold enfranchisement specialist


Insights, articles & blogs
INDEX

PROPERTY
BLOGS

LANDLORD
BLOGS

PROPERTY
ARTICLES

E-BOOKS

inshights shared - link to planetrent blogs

Landlord blog
Read landlord blog
inshights shared - link to ringley blogs

Property blogs
Read property blogs
inshights shared - link to ringley articles

Property articles
Read property articles
inshights shared - link to ringley ebooks

E-books
Read E-books

link to ringley social media facebook link to ringley social media instagram link to ringley social media linkedin link to ringley social media x-twitter
link to ringley social media x-twitter for small device
link to ringley social media linkedin for small device
link to ringley social media instagram for small device
link to ringley social media facebook for small device
  • Ringley Group
  • About us
  • CSR / ESG
  • BusyLiving
  • PlanetRent
  • Talk to us
  • Careers
  • Ask a Question
  • Insights
  • Articles
  • Blogs
  • Subscribe
  • BTR & PRS Buildings
  • What we do
  • Asset Management
  • Block Management
  • Facilities Management
  • Property Law
  • Surveying / Valuation
  • Building Engineering
  • Financial Services
  • Managing Agents
  • Block Management Locations
  • Co-working
  • Renting & Letting
  • Right to Manage
  • Contractor Management
  • Space to Work
  • Fees and Client Money Protections
  • Email: solutions@ringley.co.uk

  • Emergency line 1: 0207 428 2056

  • Emergency line 2: 0207 267 2900

  • Report an incident
  • Our Offices
  • London
  • Ringley House
  • 1 Castle Road
  • London
  • NW1 8PR
  • T: 0207 267 2900
  • London
  • Ringley House
  • 47 Rochester Place
  • London
  • NW1 9JL
  • Manchester
  • 11 Swan Street
  • Northern Quarter
  • Manchester
  • M4 5JJ
  • T: 0330 174 7777
  • Cardiff
  • 122 West Bute Street
  • Cardiff Bay
  • Cardiff
  • CF10 5LJ
  • T: 0330 174 7747
Privacy Policy
Ringley Staff Dashboard
link to ifsm website link to tpos website link to rics website link to ukgbc website link to government security industry authority website link to alep website

All content © copyright 2025. Ringley Limited. All Rights reserved. Ringley Limited, incorporated and registered in England and wales. Registered office: Ringley House, 1 Castle Road, London, NW1 8PR. Company No. 03302438
Terms of use | Privacy Policy | Modern slavery act | COVID-19 risk assessment